Even with a new fuel filter
and new fuel lines, and new spark plug, the chainsaw doesn’t start. It has plenty spark, it has plenty fuel. A compression test indicates that it is lacking in suck and squeeze. So I yank the engine expecting to discover that when I had loaned it to a friend some time back he’d run it without mix and toasted it.
To my surprise, the cylinder is still smooth and scratch free, and there is one scratch on the skirt of the piston, where a piece of ring broke off.
The piece of ring bounced around in the cylinder a few times making some tiny marks in the piston which I have deburred, and I hope to have a new ring on friday. Three bucks for the ring and nine for shipping! Sheesh. Still, if it works it will be better than a new saw. I have been looking at the new offerings by Stihl and Husqvarna, and the “Consumer” quality stuff is just not very impressive; my cheap Craftsman (Poulan) saw has run for a long time with no appreciable trouble until now, ten some years later.
Looking at the Poulan and Stihl and Husky websites, I came to the conclusion that very little separates the ‘Consumer” model Stihl and husky machines with the Poulan, these days. Seems they still both make excellent high end stuff which I cannot afford.
A friend has a Dolmar, which is an amazing saw, when it runs. It’s a prick to get started, but it will idle nicely all bloody day- we once spent a day wandering around cutting wood and never turned the saw off, it would idle in the back of the truck for as much as ten minutes between us running into some deadwood to cut, and it never even acted like it wanted to die, and it was smooth as silk to use. They sell them at a local place that I trust, and there doesn’t seem to be a separation between the ‘Pro” and “Consumer” models. The 18″ bar one is $350. I hope that the Craftsman has a good year left in it after I replace the broken ring.

I had a husqui. it was a good saw. It was so good that it caused one of my neighbors to covet it. now I don’t have one.
The new huskies basically have poulan guts now. Made me sick to see.
Bought a cheap Poulan that got good reviews in Popular Mechanics. So far so good, but we’ll see on the longevity side. Wish I had my dad’s Stihl Wood Boss from the late 70s. I met Mr Stihl when I worked in Germany. Amazing old dude.
I have a Husqvarna backpack-type leaf blower that I bought on-sale at Sears maybe 8 or so years ago, it’s run like a champ every year, always starts right up.
I’ve pretty much owned only Stihl saws, and one had a failure similar to yours. Only, the piston was actually scored. I think it was due to the fact that it hadn’t been run in a long time, perhaps a year or more, and the lubrication just wasn’t there. I’m now in the habit of replacing the gas if it’s sat around for a while, whether it’s in the saw or still in the can. It doesn’t get wasted, it goes into the HiLo. I even put a tag with the mixing date on the gas can.
I think I may try to find a Stihl saw of a somewhat older vintage and see if I can assemble something worthwhile
I would recommend my 18 inch Ryobi – except for the minor point that it is electric, heh, heh, heh.
OTOH it has a 12amp motor driving the damn thing and will cut anything I can reach with a hundred foot cord…
I can safely say that if you get a Husqvarna 455 you will not go wrong. I’ve had my fair share of cheap 18″ saws and worked on plenty of others but the Husqvarna has never failed to start or given me any kind of greif. I’m at the age where hard work is a pita, so fast, easy and dependable was worth the extra couple of bucks spent.
GMAC, you’re probably right, but I can’t budget $450 for a chainsaw right now; $350 is gonna be hard enough to come by.