It dawns on me, slowly
Why it is that I like the LeCarre books. Why “Desk Set” is one of my favorite movies. Why I love movies and books about Bletchley Circle, why the work of John Cardinal Ratzinger has always been so interesting to me.
These are all stories about/by people who use their brains hard. People think of Einstein when you speak of smart people but most of the real brains in the world go unnoticed and ignored. Researchers are some of the most interesting people I have ever known, and I have known quite a few people. And research, as it once was, is just about gone, if it is not gone already.
I had a theology professor in seminary who considered himself an “Amateur biblical scholar”.
He knew the Pentateuch back and forth, in English and in Hebrew. He could quote chapter and verse, tell you of irregularities in different translations, and could even, he thought, distinguish the work of individual translators who worked under St Jerome. He knew the Gospels in Aramaic, Greek, and English, and could recite them from memory. And not just the four, the Gnostic gospels too.
And this was where he started. He considered the knowledge he had already acquired merely a tool to use to understand the theology he taught. And he was in the bottom percentile of the graduates of his school.
I will never know what he did. I will never have the brain he did, and now that brain is in a box under the turf somewhere in south America. Lost for all eternity.
While he could hold my attention in class for five minutes at a time, I was a daydreamer, with the attention span of a fox in a henhouse. I look at him, and the carefully trained minds of my other professors, and I think, what have we done to ourselves as a species? You can find an individual here and there capable of thought but I grew up surrounded by them. I had professors who considered you illiterate unless you could read latin and greek. Which put me in that category squarely; I can still pick out some Koine but my Latin is completely atrocious (My daughter has far outpaced me).
Anyway, now I understand why this is so important. When you read someone else’s translation you take for granted their translation is as accurate as it can be, and that it gives you the actual information you’re searching for. More often than not, this is not true.
The advent of computerization has put the world at our fingertips, but we spend all our time looking at cat pictures and bitching about who is using what restroom.
11 comments Og | Uncategorized
I used to work with a guy who had learned latin as part of his high school training. He was also a fromer b52 pilot.
Sometimes I think we are slowing becoming a less capable society. I am sure some romans noticed the same thing on the way to the baths.
I think I want to be a barbarian given what I am seeing the civilized people do.
When I was taking theology, I had a prof whose first language was Vietnamese, who could read the Pentateuch in the original Hebrew in class and tell you why you’re interpretation of something in English was relying on an English ambiguity that wasn’t really there in the original.
It’s pretty impressive and made me sort of wish I had some mental feat I could pull off, like listing the first thousand prime numbers or something.
It’s not going to happen. That’s ok.
Everyone is a theologian. But there are those who have been called to make it their life’s work. They embrace the call, and you can tell they have.
My calling was different. There are some of us that need to be about the physical plant. I’m like you; I am attracted to the intelligent. My curiosity and focus can hook on to them quickly and stay there for a while. Ever the student… Always learning… At least that’s what I desire to do.
Woot! Fist bump…
Two things: I’m trying to teach myself Japanese, and learned early that I could learn to read it or learn to speak it, but in the time left to me on earth, doing both would be nearly impossible, and I realized just how dumb I really am.
Item Two: Ever wonder what the memory center of a concert pianist would look like if you could get an image of it? They commit numerous scores to memory, and play them precisely with complete recall. Oy. Now I KNOW I’m really dumb. Sigh…
We ARE dumbing down Americans one grade at a time, and one failed school system at a time…
I am living proof of our public schools failure beginning about 1965.
The purpose of educated people was to serve as “canary in a coal mine”, see Nock’s Isaiah’s Job. To say when society as a whole was about to do something stupid “Hey, better not do that”. They existed for the most part outside society (I’m also reminded of The Giver in the story by the same name, now that I think of it). Call them what you will, Intellectuals, Prophets, Academics, whatever, that’s their purpose.
The first problem was when we decided that someone’s uninformed opinion (aka FEELING) is equal to the prophet’s (I’ll use this term just because) informed opinion. So ten people who don’t know their ass from a hole in the wall outweigh one person who has all his shit in one bag (pardon the scatalogical references).
The of course the people who hunger for power (and are generally as ignorant as anyone else) noted that the Prophets were honored and often GIVEN power, combine with the idea that your ignorance is just as important as my wisdom, and the power-hungry play on that to get themselves into power, where they can make the decisions affecting society.
Third, the prophet had two other functions, in addition to the canary-in-a-coal-mine. He had to teach EVERYONE some basics in literature, philosophy, and history (the very tools he himself used to give warnings), so that everyone would have a basic, broad-based understanding of society so they could make certain decisions themselves AND understand his warnings when he gave them. Finally, he had to find that once-in-a-generation person who could be the NEXT prophet (just as Elijah found Elisha), so the process could continue.
Education has now also been taken over by the power-hungry, the next generation of teachers is chosen from the substandard students created by those teachers, and the canary’s cage is empty.
At least that’s how I see it. I don’t pretend to be a prophet.
“The advent of computerization has put the world at our fingertips, but we spend all our time looking at cat pictures and bitching about who is using what restroom.” – Og
That reminds me of this:
https://youtu.be/FL9bylhDkcc?t=22s
“Gentlemen, gentlemen. I don’t understand it. All these books. A world of knowledge at your fingertips and what do you do? Play poker all night.”
Unfortunately, it also reminds me of this:
https://youtu.be/fooeHIC3ENY?t=28s
“I will never know what he did. I will never have the brain he did, and now that brain is in a box under the turf somewhere in south America. Lost for all eternity.”
Are you sure? I hope not.
I am sure his brain is in that box. I’m pretty sure I’ll never be the scholar he was. And as for it being lost, the learning of this world would be useless to the next, so whatever conjecture he may have had while he was here, I’m confident he is aware of the truth now.
“The advent of computerization has put the world at our fingertips, but we spend all our time looking at cat pictures and bitching about who is using what restroom.” IOW we can piss up a rope one mile wide, but we barely wet the surface. The people who get depth out of a computer are not there to kiss the computer’s glossy lips.